‘Like its predecessors, it is notable for the clarity of its prose, the thoughtfulness with which it has been edited, its high production values, and the pleasing range and variety of its contributions’, Kimberley Reynolds, Inis.
'It is a commendable addition to the growing number of publications in the field', Emer O'Sullivan, Irish Times.
‘The essays explore themes and issues which are equally important for Irish and British students and teachers, and the quality of critical writing is mostly high … [A] well worth acquisition for college libraries across the United Kingdom’, Peter Hollindale, School Librarian (Winter 2007).